Tideland (2005)

31 out of 35 people found the following review helpful:

Alice in Wonderland meets Psycho

Halliwelll from , 26th January, 2007

Described by Gilliam as “Alice in Wonderland meets Psycho” – this poetically faithful, low budget adaptation of Mitch Cullin’s novel, is arguable his most disturbing and distinctive film to-date. Bold and original, this painful odyssey within a lonely child’s imagination has a strange awkward beauty that will not be to everyone’s taste. Gilliam’s approach to visual language is radical; he is prepared to take enormous risks while paying attention to the smallest texture and details. When it pays off, as it does in the accurate sense of scale of this tiny female narrator’s inner world - it is a wondrous achievement. Jeliza Rose (Jodelle Ferland) sits inside the topsy-turvy landscape of an upturned bus, conversing with a chorus of disembodied Barbie doll heads. Although this, the first of many dark claustrophobic interiors, may briefly light up with CGI generated firefly fairies, rest assured, this is not Disney. Jeliza’s train wreck of a family swiftly derails any romanticised notions of childhood. After her abusive, bloated, chocoholic mother (Jennifer Tilley), dies of a methadone overdose, Jeliza and her drug addled, aging, rock star father (Jeff Bridges) set off in true fairy tale style to grandma’s house. However, grandmas’ long dead, the house a dilapidated ruin and now after his last hit father rigidly stares at the wall while emitting strange smells. Cast adrift in the wild oceanic beauty of the surrounding Saskatchewan prairies and Pecorini’s ravishing widescreen lensing, Jeliza appears shipwrecked in an Andrew Wyeth painting. Emotionally and physically starving Jeliza encounters a talking squirrel, an eccentric taxidermist in a black beekeeper’s bonnet (Janet McTeer) and the brave sea captain and slayer of the monster shark (Brendan Fletcher). The most authentic testament of a child’s attempt to survive neglect and abuse, and affecting exploration of the consequences of using fantasy as a coping mechanism since TARNATION.

Read all highest rated reviews

23 out of 26 people found the following review helpful:

Bizarre, disturbing but very engaging.

Hanna Natalia from greater manchester, 26th August, 2006

WOW! this film, just as Gilliam warns, will really divide opinion. whilst certainly containing some of the most horrifying, even digusting, scenes i have ever witnessed, it is surreal,and at times, enchanting, to attract the audience as it repels. there is some stunning imagery and breath-taking fantasy woven through the repulsive spectacle of rotting corpses and suggestion of necro and peaodophilia and the obvious unease, to understate ridiculously, of watching a child near starve to death. not for everyone. whether you see this or not, you'll probably regret it.

Read all highest rated reviews

20 out of 26 people found the following review helpful:

Oh dear. Oh dear, oh dear.......Terry, we need a word.

Bonyman from London, 15th March, 2007

Dear Mr Gilliam. You introduced this film with an announcement. Some of us weren't going to like what we were about to see. Damn right (and not a great way to set up your audience). So let's look at the reasoning for your apology - the film we were about to see is seen through the eyes of a child, or a child's imagination if you like. Great, I can accept that. As we grow older, we lose sight of what it is to be a child, to see the world with such innocence. No, not me, not got a problem with that. The problem I do have, Mr G, is that it's all very well delivering a film through the eyes of a child, but the story we see still has to be dramatic. And by that, I don't expect car chases, explosions (though you deliver there, eventually) or kung-fu. But equally, I don't want to be waiting and waiting for something to happen, some kind of arc or shape to the narrative that really engages me. There's nothing wrong with the accents, nothing really wrong with the performances. But film is about story. And I just didn't care. I really, really wanted to like this and had great expectations. But, I'm afraid, you were right. Some of us weren't going to like it. Note to audience: If self-indulgence is your thing, jump right in.

Read all highest rated reviews

12 out of 17 people found the following review helpful:

Gilliam's masterpiece

Lydia Jones from London, 31st January, 2007

While at times uncomfortable viewing, Gilliam knows when to draw the line. Beautifully told in true Gilliam style; camera angles to disorientate the viewer and the brilliant juxtaposition of the open landscape of the fields with the dark claustrophobic interiors. I loved this film and it's Terry's best by a mile - beautiful, fantastical yet awkwardly real at the same time.

Read all highest rated reviews

Tideland

A Customer from Billingham, 9th November, 2008

Terry Gilliam at his most personal and magical. His personally filmed plea on the DVD, suggests that the film was greeted unpleasantly an its cinematic release. It is unquestionably a complex and challenging tale of childhood, that rewards an open mind and a generous forgiving heart.

Read all recent reviews

DONT DO IT

Idene from from Newcastle Upon Tyne, 20th October, 2008

Basically, at the start of this DVD the director comes on and tells ya that some people love this film and most hate it. There's a good reason why most people hate it.

Read all recent reviews

very stereotyped characters, but the execution is fantastic

Ellesar from from London, 24th September, 2008

I am always impressed by good child performances because, although most children are great fantasists they are usually rubbish actors. Of course this child was free to make up some of the stuff she did, but there is a lot of script, and it is a 'challenging' story. Gilliam talks about a childs resilience, and while I agree that children are often a lot tougher than we give them credit for that resilience has to come from somewhere. I think that it is wildly unrealistic to suppose that a child with 2 heroin addicted parents would have looked so healthy or been so able to cope. Yes, many children do parent their parents, but they have to have support from somewhere, and there is no indication that Juliza Rose has ever has that. I have seen the children of addicted parents, and they do not have the delightful bohemian look of this character, and express more disturbed behaviour traits. The adult characters are unrelentingly stereotyped - the junkie parents, the crazy or mentally subnormal hicks who live in a remote farmhouse. I did feel that it was a tad sensationalistic. These characters were formed in a novel, so this is not Gilliam creating them, and the way they are depicted on screen is good - great performances. I do feel that Juliza Rose would have reacted strongly at some point to the horrors going on - esp the scene where Dell character is doing what she does to keep JR's father in the house - resilience does not mean that you would not have a freak out about horrific events, even if they have become normalised to an extent. That she takes it all as normal and necessary is just pushing that a bit too far. Her relationship with Dickens has been controversial, but I did not find it to be disturbing - it was appropriate and not at all exploitative. But people with learning difficulties do have sexual feelings, and do not necessarily understand the appropriate outlets. In this case it was fine, but again, realistically it probably wouldn't have been. I loved the look of the film, and the fantasy scenes. I am very much in touch with that rich fantasy world that I inhabited as a child, and I do like to see depictions of it. The dolls heads on the fingers is brilliant - if their voices were the child actors then she truly is a brilliant actor. This is a film I will watch again and again.

Read all recent reviews

Non-typical Gilliam

Emsels from from Bristol, 17th August, 2008

This is a great movie. It is truly wacky, weird and fun. It invokes particular feelings and emotions from the viewer and it could go anyway at any moment I had no idea how it would end. Totally what I love in films. I'm a big Gilliam fan but I wouldn't have guessed it was him (apart from a few of the camera moves) from the content. If you want something different I highly recommend it.

Read all recent reviews