10 out of 10 people found the following review helpful:
Disappointing for a french movie
Bruce M from Oxford, England,
10th November, 2004
Well, I guess there is no reason that the French should always produce a more sensitive movie than other countries, but I was very disappointed with this movie. Well acted, good cinematography, and a plausible plot with dept, i.e. a young popular 'sports' star, also good at the books, coming out, or in this case being outed, and having to deal with this at his school, and with his family. A good starting point, but the subject matter was not dealt with in a feels 'true' to life manner. Things that got to me: lots and lots of female nudity, but very little male nudity, and when showing it, in the dark. Good grief, can't we have 'equal' showing, particularly for a 'gay coming out' movie? Or, just don't show any at all. But don't keep focussing on the young ladie's breasts. I've been in a lot of 'sports' groups, and this is the first time I've seen a group of young men, taking communal showers, and keeping their trunks on. Have things changed so much in France? When is the last time you've been in a locker room and seen the guys walk in every time after swimming, and not immediately strip off. The other item that really bugged me was the reaction of the gay boy's team mates, and class mates. Sorry, although homophobia is certainly alive, I question that everyone (except for his two best friends), that is of this age would viciously turn against him. This is saying that young people of 15-18 are not able to form their own thoughts, and in many many cases, unless we are talking forty/fifty years ago, adolescents who know well another one who comes out (and are friends with them, or otherwise respect them), are not going to be so bothered by that person's sexuality. Yes, there will be some people who turn against him/her, but not everyone!! So, although well filmed, decent acting, etc., the plot just did not ring at all true to real life, which was particularly disappointing for a French movie (although why I should expect more, I'm not sure, but I normally do).
Read all highest rated reviews